The Wagners - A Serious Injury Law Firm blog shares Personal Injury stories and opinions relevant to Halifax, Nova Scotia residents. Let us know what you think.

Doctor Commits Medical Malpractice: Medical Care Required to be Informed by Hospital Policies

by | Friday, October 11, 2013

A new medical malpractice decision from the Court of Appeal was released earlier this summer. It affirms a finding of medical negligence on the part of a doctor. This case is important in that it highlights that issues concerning the responsibilities of the various doctors involved in a patient’s care must be considered in light of a Hospital’s policies.

A young lady was 36 weeks pregnant when she went into the Hospital with a severe, sudden onset of chest pain and shortness of breath.

Her doctors suspected either a pulmonary embolism, a blood clot in the lung, or an aortic dissection, a tear in the wall of the aorta. Both are serious, life-threatening conditions. The doctors ordered various tests and admitted her to the Hospital.

After approximately a one week stay in Hospital, the patient was scheduled to be discharged. Sadly, shortly before her discharge, she collapsed on the floor and died from a ruptured ascending aortic aneurism. Fortunately, her daughter was successfully delivered by an emergency caesarean section.

The young mother’s husband hired personal injury lawyers to commence a medical malpractice lawsuit against the doctors, nurses and the Hospital. In particular, the action focused on her obstetrician, the doctor designated to be her “Most Responsible Physician”.

At trial, the trial judge found that the obstetrician acted negligently for failing to treat the woman’s heart-related problems as an emergency requiring an immediate cardiac consultation and transfer to a tertiary care centre. This finding came in spite of the obstetrician’s argument that he was entitled to rely on the reasonable advice of a qualified consulting respirologist.

The doctor appealed the trial decision.

The Court of Appeal found also found that the doctor had committed medical malpractice and that he was responsible for the plaintiffs’ injuries. The decision largely focused on the Hospital Policy:


“The Most Responsible Practitioner/Attending Practitioner” (MRP) is the practitioner most responsible for the hospital care of a particular patient. The MRP is responsible for writing and clarifying orders, and providing a plan of care, obtaining consultations as appropriate, coordinating care, as well as the discharge process. Staff concerns about a patient should be directed to the MRP.

The MRP is to maintain communication with the patient’s relatives and maintain/liaison if necessary, with consultants and family practitioners involved in the patient’s care.

The MRP will be the admitting practitioner or such other practitioner to whom the patient has been transferred, from time to time, in accordance with the Rules. There shall be only one practitioner at any one time referred to as the most responsible practitioner.

The Court judge found that the obstetrician did not exercise critical judgment or provide an appropriate plan of care for his pregnant patient and, accordingly, failed to fulfill his responsibilities as the MRP. This was found to amount to medical malpractice.

The Court further agreed that the medical negligence resulted in the unfortunate death of the young patient. It held that had the doctor not abdicated his responsibility to his patient, the cardiac evaluation of her and her transfer to a tertiary care centre where additional expertise and facilities were available, the necessary surgery could have been completed days before her untimely death (thus, it could have been prevented).

Sam M
Sam M
16:11 19 Jan 18
Dyana was so kind to help me and respond to my query within 24h even though they do not pursue the specific class action I was looking for. She sent me few links by email. Thank you Dyana.
linda frausell
linda frausell
01:21 16 May 17
I have dealt with Wagner and Associates over the years and have received great advice,support and results . Their team is very respectful and show they care. You can trust them to take care of you and they always have your best interest in hand. I would definetly recommend them .
frank slaunwhite
frank slaunwhite
16:29 03 May 17
Ray Wagner and his legal team have been representing my niece and I for many years. They have been honest and quick to respond to all our needs in a professional manner. I highly recommend Wagners Law Firm and appreciate their caring approach.Thanks
Missy Day
Missy Day
12:03 06 Oct 16
I can't speak highly enough about the lawyers at Wagners who represented me for injuries from not one but two motor vehicle accidents. They were very professional and approachable. I was kept informed of all steps in the process and all of my inquiries were responded to and dealt with very quickly. The lawyers are knowledgeable and showed great empathy for what I was going through. I would recommend this firm to anyone!
Nicholas Gordon
Nicholas Gordon
11:30 06 Oct 16
I contacted Wagners about a motor vehicle accident.I was able to speak with someone right away. The staff were very pleasant and helpful.I received a response about pursuing a case the next day.I would highly recommend this firm.
See All Reviews